When Did You Know

The singer questions if the other person realized during an intimate moment in Jackson Hole that the relationship was ending.

Refers to a specific romantic moment by a fire in Jackson Hole, emphasizing the setting of a potential turning point in the relationship.

The singer wonders if the partner was aware that they would eventually break up during the mentioned romantic encounter.

Questions if the partner knew that the singer was developing strong feelings during their journey back home.

Expresses the singer's deepening emotions and attachment to the partner during the trip home.

The singer initially believed the partner was "the one" for them.

The singer questions if the partner was only seeking enjoyment and not committed to the relationship.

Directly asks when the partner became aware that the relationship wasn't destined for a long-term commitment.

Reflects on the realization that the relationship wasn't going to last forever.

Expresses the irony of being physically close but emotionally distant.

Questions the paradox of being close but not together, highlighting the emotional disconnect.

The singer reflects on shattered dreams and questions the partner's intentions.

The entire relationship is reduced to a single question, emphasizing its significance.

Asks when the partner realized that their feelings weren't based on genuine love.

Reiterates the question, specifically addressing the partner's realization that it wasn't the singer they loved.

Questions how the partner could treat the singer in a way that caused emotional distress.

Highlights the partner's apparent lack of emotional investment or empathy.

Expresses the pain caused by the partner's actions and seeks an explanation for the hurtful behavior.

Questions how the partner can be emotionally detached while causing intense emotions in the singer.

Contrasts the partner's emotional detachment with the impact of their actions on the singer's soul.

The singer expresses confusion and a lack of understanding regarding the partner's behavior.

The singer is still trying to recover and comprehend the situation, feeling emotionally overwhelmed.

Repeats the question of when the partner became aware that the relationship wasn't long-lasting.

Reiterates the realization that the relationship wasn't meant to last forever.

Highlights the paradox of physical closeness coexisting with emotional distance.

Repeats the theme of being close but not together, emphasizing the emotional disconnect.

Reflects on shattered dreams and questions the partner's intentions.

The entire relationship is reduced to a single question, underlining its profound impact.

Repeats the question of when the partner realized that their feelings weren't based on genuine love.

Reiterates the question, specifically addressing the partner's realization that it wasn't the singer they loved.

Reiterates the reflection on shattered dreams and questions the partner's intentions.

The entire relationship is once again reduced to a single question, reinforcing its significance.

Repeats the question of when the partner became aware that the relationship wasn't long-lasting.

Reiterates the realization that the relationship wasn't meant to last forever.

The final plea for the partner to reveal when they knew the relationship was doomed.